Tag: listening

  • Chicago area investigative reporting review: February-March 2026

    March 22 @ 2:00 pm – 3:00 pm CDT

    This is the continuing Fourth Wednesday evening time for monthly discussion of  the topics raised by recent Chicago area investigative reporting (if Sunday afternoons are more convenient, join us on Fourth Sundays). We use a mid-month to mid-month timeframe for these late month time slots, so this month, we’re looking at  February 16-March 15 publishing dates. What we spend the most time on depends on where the interest of the group lies.

    Google-generated summary follows. The list is assembled by a Google’s NotebookLM and Claude’s Opus 4.6, both of which (“whom”?) can and will make mistakes as well as the fuzzier domain of “errors of judgment”, so if you think it’s missed something important or is mistaking a conclusion, please email Ken Novak. 

    The biggest news is the City’s Office of Inspector General (OIG) issuing its annual Public Safety 2026 Annual Outlook, outlining its priorities for improving police accountability and discipline in the year ahead.

    The OIG also issued reports:

    • highlighting an underperforming 311 service system, described by frustrated residents as an unresponsive “black hole” for basic city repairs;  
    • flagging concerns about the city’s Department of Law improperly withholding hiring records from oversight; 
    • recommending reopening a disciplinary investigation into an officer who reportedly brandished a gun at the Westinghouse High School student.

    Separately, an Injustice Watch investigation reveals systemic exploitation of Cook County’s tax foreclosure system, detailing a suspected fraud scheme involving recycled photographs and bogus court filings used to obtain millions of dollars in government refunds.

    Public Safety And Employment Oversight

    Between mid-February and early March 2026, the OIG issued multiple reports regarding city employment actions and police accountability (2, 4, 5). On February 17, 2026, the OIG published its 2026 outlook on police oversight, outlining efforts to improve the accountability and transparency of the Chicago Police Department and its disciplinary processes (4). Ten days later, on February 27, 2026, the OIG formally recommended reopening a specific CPD disciplinary investigation (5). On March 4, 2026, the OIG published an advisory concerning the Department of Law, noting that the department had improperly refused to provide “high profile” hiring records before eventually producing them in response to a covert Freedom of Information Act request (2).

    City 311 Service Request System Audit

    An audit by the City of Chicago Office of Inspector General (OIG) concluded that the city’s 311 service request system fails to provide users with clear information regarding request statuses, work order timeframes, or overall processes (3, 6). The OIG noted that community members described the system as a “black hole,” with residents reporting that online requests were frequently marked “complete” even when physical issues, such as unpatched potholes, remained unresolved in their neighborhoods (3, 6). The audit also identified that the 311 system has limited staffing capacity to proactively analyze complaint data to improve city services (3).

    In response to the findings, the Office of Emergency Management and Communications (OEMC), which manages 311, acknowledged the need for improved communication with the public (3, 6). OEMC also stated that there is a need for more consistent training and communication with other city departments to address the system’s current limitations (3).

    Tax Foreclosure Fraud Allegations

    An investigation by the Cook County Treasurer’s Office identified what its researchers described to law enforcement as a “sophisticated conspiracy” involving real estate investor Greg Bingham (1). The internal probe alleged that Bingham’s companies filed fraudulent records — including recycled photographs of property damage with doctored dates, false affidavits, and bogus bankruptcy petitions — to exploit sale-in-error provisions in state law and obtain government refunds. The largest category of suspected fraud involved 145 refund cases from 2018 to 2024 that contained duplicate or doctored photographs, totaling more than $3 million (1). These refunds were paid by dipping into funds earmarked for municipal budgets, schools, parks, and libraries (1).

    The Treasurer’s Office shared its findings with the FBI and the Cook County State’s Attorney’s Office, detailing instances where Bingham allegedly doctored dates on photographs submitted to Cook County judges (1). Bingham denies the allegations and has not been charged with a crime, while a spokesperson for the Cook County State’s Attorney confirmed their inquiry remains an active, pending investigation (1).

    Source Citations

    1. Ballesteros, Carlos. “Taken by Taxes: The King of Liens.” Injustice Watch, March 12, 2026. https://www.injusticewatch.org/project/taken-by-taxes/2026/greg-bingham-king-of-liens/
    2. Chicago Office of Inspector General. “Advisory on Department of Law’s Cooperation with Oversight of Its Employment Actions.” Chicago Office of Inspector General, March 4, 2026. https://igchicago.org/publications/advisory-on-department-of-laws-cooperation-with-oversight-of-its-employment-actions/
    3. Chicago Office of Inspector General. “OIG Finds Lack of Clarity, Transparency in the 311 Request Process, Limiting Its Potential to Improve City Services and Risking Public Distrust.” Chicago Office of Inspector General, February 26, 2026. https://igchicago.org/2026/02/26/oig-finds-lack-of-clarity-transparency-in-the-311-request-process/
    4. Chicago Office of Inspector General. “Public Safety 2026 Outlook on Police Oversight and Accountability.” Chicago Office of Inspector General, February 17, 2026. https://igchicago.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/OIG-Public-Safety-2026-Annual-Outlook-.pdf
    5. Chicago Office of Inspector General. “Recommendation to Reopen Chicago Police Department Disciplinary Investigation.” Chicago Office of Inspector General, February 27, 2026. https://igchicago.org/publications/rec-to-reopen-cpd-log-2021-0004611/
    6. Feurer, Todd. “Chicago inspector general recommends changes to city’s 311 service request system.” CBS Chicago, February 26, 2026. https://www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/chicago-inspector-general-audit-311-service-request-system/

    Ken Novak is the President and the Program|Communications chair of the Circle.

    https://bit.ly/cehcsunday

    or

    https://us02web.zoom.us/j/88112982706?pwd=SlRldUpsQzBibHBEdUN3ZzhxcUlPQT09

    847 414-4314

  • Great Documents Discussion: Bertrand Russell’s “What I Believe”

    Great Documents Discussion: Bertrand Russell’s “What I Believe”

    March 8 @ 2:00 pm – 3:30 pm CDT

    On Sunday, March 8, at 2 PM CT/3 pm ET, we will discuss Bertrand Russell’s “What I Believe”, published in 1925.

    “What I Believe (Project Gutenberg page) details Russell’s framework for understanding humanity’s place in the physical universe and his criteria for ethical behavior. Russell argues that religious beliefs, including dogmas regarding gods and immortality, lack scientific evidence and originate primarily from a human fear of nature.

    He asserts that “the good life is one inspired by love and guided by knowledge”. Rather than adhering to theological texts or traditions, he proposes that human conduct should be evaluated by its probable consequences and its effectiveness in achieving widely desired social ends. The text advocates utilizing scientific knowledge and methods to mitigate preventable suffering, manage human desires, and improve societal conditions.

    The positions Russell articulated in “What I Believe” became central evidence fifteen years later. After the City Colleges of New York appointed Russell to a teaching position in 1940, opposition resulted in a taxpayer lawsuit to void the appointment. The plaintiff’s counsel cited “What I Believe”, and three of Russell’s other works, to argue that his written views on religion and marriage made him legally unfit to instruct students. The presiding judge revoked Russell’s appointment. Ten years after that, Russell was awarded the 1950 Nobel Prize in Literature “in recognition of his varied and significant writings in which he champions humanitarian ideals and freedom of thought”.

    No need to read the essay. We’ll briefly recapitulate it to lead into discussion. Questions? Call Ken Novak (847) 414-4314 or email him.

    Join us!

    Here’s the Zoom link: https://bit.ly/cehcsunday

    Here is a summary of the essay:

    Chapter I: Nature and Man

    Russell begins by arguing that man is fundamentally a part of nature, governed by the same physical laws as stars and atoms.

    Because human thoughts and mental phenomena are inextricably tied to the physical structure of the brain, there is no scientific basis for the belief in life after death or an immortal soul. Furthermore, he argues that the central dogmas of the Christian religion, such as God and immortality, are not supported by science. Instead, religion is primarily born out of humanity’s fear of nature and death.

    While humans are physically subordinate to a universe that is completely neutral—neither good nor bad—Russell asserts that in the realm of philosophy and values, humans are “kings”. It is up to human desires, not nature or a deity, to determine and create what is valuable.

    Chapter II: The Good Life

    The central thesis of Russell’s philosophy is that “the good life is one inspired by love and guided by knowledge”.

    Love exists on a spectrum between pure delight (aesthetic contemplation) and pure benevolence (desiring the welfare of another). However, love alone is insufficient without knowledge, which Russell defines not as abstract “ethical knowledge,” but as scientific understanding of how to actually achieve our desired ends.

    Russell rejects the idea of objective moral standards outside of human desires, arguing instead that conduct should be judged purely by its probable consequences and its ability to realize social purposes that humanity widely desires.

    Chapter III: Moral Rules

    Russell argues that moral rules are a practical necessity designed to manage the conflict of human desires. However, he criticizes “current morality” as a blend of utilitarianism and superstition. Superstitious morality, rooted in the fear of divine wrath, leads to immense and preventable cruelty.

    He points to traditional moral codes surrounding sex, birth control, and marriage, arguing that they inflict needless suffering on parents and children by condemning actions that do no real harm.

    Additionally, he argues that society’s treatment of criminals is driven by superstitious notions of “sin” and vindictive cruelty; instead, society should treat criminals scientifically, much like people suffering from a contagious disease, focusing on prevention and cure rather than punishment.

    Chapter IV: Salvation: Individual and Social

    Russell critiques the traditional religious focus on “individual salvation”. He argues that a person cannot truly live the good life in isolation, because the good life requires a multitude of supportive social conditions, such as education, health, and freedom from extreme poverty.

    He also rejects the aristocratic ideal, which limits human sympathy by exploiting others, and the romantic illusion that society can be suddenly “saved” through catastrophic revolutions. True salvation is social, and it requires a gradual, quantitative improvement of intelligence, self-control, and sympathy.

    Chapter V: Science and Happiness

    Finally, Russell addresses how science can actively improve human behavior and happiness. He notes that human harmfulness largely stems from ignorance or bad desires—particularly active malevolence, which is driven by fear and envy. To build a happier world, society must combat fear by increasing physical and economic security and by democratizing courage.

    Russell also warns against the philosophical worship of “nature,” arguing that humanity should not passively accept “natural” suffering like overpopulation or disease. Ultimately, he concludes that if humanity can conquer its own passions, science possesses an almost limitless potential to improve health, character, and happiness, allowing us to finally win our freedom.


    Join us on Sunday to unpack these ideas and relate them to today.

    847 414-4314

  • Chicago area investigative reporting review: January-February 2026

    February 25 @ 7:00 pm – 8:00 pm CST

    There are two alternative times for monthly discussion of  the topics raised by recent Chicago area investigative reporting. This month we’re settling into a mid-month to mid-month timeframe for these late month time slots, so this month, we’re looking at January 16-February 15 publishing dates. What we spend the most time on depends on where the interest of the group lies. The list is assembled by a Google’s NotebookLM, which can and will make mistakes as well as the fuzzier domain of “errors of judgment”, so if you think it’s missed something important, please email Ken Novak. 

    No need to read the articles. We’ll summarize key articles to lead into discussion. Questions? Call Ken Novak (847) 414-4314 or email him.

    Join us! Here is the summary and the links of the stories we’ll discuss:

    Federal Immigration Raids and Mayor’s Executive Order

    Recent investigations revealed that dramatic “midnight raids” by federal agents in Chicago were driven by routine complaints of squatting rather than a “terrorist takeover” by a Venezuelan gang, as initially claimed by the Trump administration. ProPublica uncovered documents showing the government’s own intelligence contradicted its public narrative regarding the apartment complex (8).

    In response to the escalation of federal enforcement, Mayor Brandon Johnson issued an executive order. This directive requires Chicago police to document and investigate alleged illegal actions and constitutional violations by federal agents operating within the city. We’ll review the new rules (6).

    City Overtime Mismanagement

    On January 21, 2026, the Chicago Office of Inspector General (OIG) released an advisory report detailing severe financial mismanagement regarding city payroll. The investigation found that between 2020 and 2024, the city mispaid $26.5 million in overtime to more than 1,000 employees who were explicitly ineligible for such compensation (1).

    The watchdog report (9) highlighted a highly concentrated area of abuse within the payroll system. Out of the vast number of employees who received improper payments, just 18 individuals accounted for nearly a quarter of the total $26.5 million dispersed (1).

    Judicial Accountability

    The Illinois Supreme Court took decisive action on January 26, 2026, by removing Judge James Brown from the bench. This removal followed intense scrutiny generated by an Injustice Watch investigation into the judge’s conduct both in and out of the courtroom. (5)

    Reporting exposed that Judge Brown had maintained a “conspiracy-filled blog post” and demonstrated clear courtroom bias. The revelations prompted multiple lawyer groups to label his actions as “blatantly disrespectful” and successfully push for his immediate removal from the judicial system. (4)

    Economic and Social Pressures

    Investigative outlets also focused heavily on the economic burdens facing Chicago residents. City Bureau reported on new SNAP work requirements that took effect on February 1, 2026, which safety net organizations warn will endanger food benefits for nearly 400,000 Illinoisans. (2)

    If you or someone you know needs food, visit the Greater Chicago Food Depository website, Feeding Illinois or the Find Food IL interactive map to locate assistance near you. You can also find support through the Chicago Area Mutual Aid Map and Directory.

    Simultaneously, the Illinois Answers Project and The Chicago Reporter scrutinized the state’s massive investments in new technology infrastructure. Illinois Answers reporters examined the 128-acre Illinois Quantum & Microelectronics Park for having exceptionally high state funding per job created, while The Chicago Reporter investigating how the proliferation of data centers is driving up local energy bills through “cost shifts” and creating environmental concerns for nearby communities (3, 7).

    Source Citations

    1. Cherone, Heather. “City Paid $26.5M in Overtime to Ineligible Employees: Watchdog.” WTTW News, January 21, 2026. https://news.wttw.com/2026/01/21/city-paid-265m-overtime-ineligible-employees-watchdog

    2. City Bureau. “SNAP Cuts Puts Families at Risk, Advocates Say.” City Bureau, February 11, 2026. https://www.citybureau.org/newswire/2026/2/11/snap-cuts-puts-families-at-risk

    3. Henrickson, Kimberly. “How Data Centers Are Driving Up Chicagoans’ Energy Bills.” The Chicago Reporter, February 12, 2026. https://www.chicagoreporter.com/how-data-centers-are-driving-up-chicagoans-energy-bills/

    4. Dai, Melissa. “‘Blatantly disrespectful’: Lawyer groups push for removal of reinstated judge.” Injustice Watch, January 22, 2026. https://www.injusticewatch.org/judges/judicial-conduct/2026/james-brown-cook-county-judge-recall/

    5. Dai, Melissa. “Illinois Supreme Court removes reinstated judge following rebuke of conspiracy-filled blog post.” Injustice Watch, January 26, 2026. https://www.injusticewatch.org/judges/judicial-conduct/2026/james-brown-cook-county-judge-removed/

    6. Helmore, Edward. “Chicago mayor orders police to investigate alleged illegal ICE activity in city.” The Guardian, January 31, 2026. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/jan/31/chicago-ice-brandon-johnson

    7. Huang, Binghui, and Andrew Adams. “Chicago’s quantum hub has some of the highest state funding per job. Here’s the breakdown.” Illinois Answers Project, February 5, 2026. https://illinoisanswers.org/2026/02/05/chicagos-quantum-hub-has-some-of-the-highest-state-funding-per-job-heres-the-breakdown/

    8. Sanchez, Melissa, and Jodi S. Cohen. “The Real Story Behind the Midnight Immigration Raid on a Chicago Apartment Building.” ProPublica, February 4, 2026. https://www.propublica.org/article/chicago-venezuela-immigration-ice-raid-landlord-tren-de-aragua

    9. City of Chicago Office of Inspector General. “Advisory Concerning Overtime Payments to Ineligible Employees.” January 21, 2026. https://news.wttw.com/sites/default/files/article/file-attachments/Advisory-Concerning-Overtime-Payments-to-Ineligible-Employees.pdf

    Ken Novak is the President and the Program|Communications chair of the Circle.

    https://bit.ly/cehcmidweek or

    https://us02web.zoom.us/j/85380171176?pwd=bFQ4bzRULytTeFNDK0pSS05ISFVWdz09

    847 414-4314

  • Chicago area investigative reporting review: January-February 2026

    February 22 @ 2:00 pm – 3:00 pm CST

    There are two alternative times for monthly discussion of  the topics raised by recent Chicago area investigative reporting. This month we’re settling into a mid-month to mid-month timeframe for these late month time slots, so this month, we’re looking at January 16-February 15 publishing dates. What we spend the most time on depends on where the interest of the group lies. The list is assembled by a Google’s NotebookLM, which can and will make mistakes as well as the fuzzier domain of “errors of judgment”, so if you think it’s missed something important, please email Ken Novak. 

    No need to read the articles. We’ll summarize key articles to lead into discussion. Questions? Call Ken Novak (847) 414-4314 or email him.

    Join us! Here is the summary and the links of the stories we’ll discuss:

    Federal Immigration Raids and Mayor’s Executive Order

    Recent investigations revealed that dramatic “midnight raids” by federal agents in Chicago were driven by routine complaints of squatting rather than a “terrorist takeover” by a Venezuelan gang, as initially claimed by the Trump administration. ProPublica uncovered documents showing the government’s own intelligence contradicted its public narrative regarding the apartment complex (8).

    In response to the escalation of federal enforcement, Mayor Brandon Johnson issued an executive order. This directive requires Chicago police to document and investigate alleged illegal actions and constitutional violations by federal agents operating within the city. We’ll review the new rules (6).

    City Overtime Mismanagement

    On January 21, 2026, the Chicago Office of Inspector General (OIG) released an advisory report detailing severe financial mismanagement regarding city payroll. The investigation found that between 2020 and 2024, the city mispaid $26.5 million in overtime to more than 1,000 employees who were explicitly ineligible for such compensation (1).

    The watchdog report (9) highlighted a highly concentrated area of abuse within the payroll system. Out of the vast number of employees who received improper payments, just 18 individuals accounted for nearly a quarter of the total $26.5 million dispersed (1).

    Judicial Accountability

    The Illinois Supreme Court took decisive action on January 26, 2026, by removing Judge James Brown from the bench. This removal followed intense scrutiny generated by an Injustice Watch investigation into the judge’s conduct both in and out of the courtroom. (5)

    Reporting exposed that Judge Brown had maintained a “conspiracy-filled blog post” and demonstrated clear courtroom bias. The revelations prompted multiple lawyer groups to label his actions as “blatantly disrespectful” and successfully push for his immediate removal from the judicial system. (4)

    Economic and Social Pressures

    Investigative outlets also focused heavily on the economic burdens facing Chicago residents. City Bureau reported on new SNAP work requirements that took effect on February 1, 2026, which safety net organizations warn will endanger food benefits for nearly 400,000 Illinoisans. (2)

    If you or someone you know needs food, visit the Greater Chicago Food Depository website, Feeding Illinois or the Find Food IL interactive map to locate assistance near you. You can also find support through the Chicago Area Mutual Aid Map and Directory.

    Simultaneously, the Illinois Answers Project and The Chicago Reporter scrutinized the state’s massive investments in new technology infrastructure. Illinois Answers reporters examined the 128-acre Illinois Quantum & Microelectronics Park for having exceptionally high state funding per job created, while The Chicago Reporter investigating how the proliferation of data centers is driving up local energy bills through “cost shifts” and creating environmental concerns for nearby communities (3, 7).

    Source Citations

    1. Cherone, Heather. “City Paid $26.5M in Overtime to Ineligible Employees: Watchdog.” WTTW News, January 21, 2026. https://news.wttw.com/2026/01/21/city-paid-265m-overtime-ineligible-employees-watchdog

    2. City Bureau. “SNAP Cuts Puts Families at Risk, Advocates Say.” City Bureau, February 11, 2026. https://www.citybureau.org/newswire/2026/2/11/snap-cuts-puts-families-at-risk

    3. Henrickson, Kimberly. “How Data Centers Are Driving Up Chicagoans’ Energy Bills.” The Chicago Reporter, February 12, 2026. https://www.chicagoreporter.com/how-data-centers-are-driving-up-chicagoans-energy-bills/

    4. Dai, Melissa. “‘Blatantly disrespectful’: Lawyer groups push for removal of reinstated judge.” Injustice Watch, January 22, 2026. https://www.injusticewatch.org/judges/judicial-conduct/2026/james-brown-cook-county-judge-recall/

    5. Dai, Melissa. “Illinois Supreme Court removes reinstated judge following rebuke of conspiracy-filled blog post.” Injustice Watch, January 26, 2026. https://www.injusticewatch.org/judges/judicial-conduct/2026/james-brown-cook-county-judge-removed/

    6. Helmore, Edward. “Chicago mayor orders police to investigate alleged illegal ICE activity in city.” The Guardian, January 31, 2026. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/jan/31/chicago-ice-brandon-johnson

    7. Huang, Binghui, and Andrew Adams. “Chicago’s quantum hub has some of the highest state funding per job. Here’s the breakdown.” Illinois Answers Project, February 5, 2026. https://illinoisanswers.org/2026/02/05/chicagos-quantum-hub-has-some-of-the-highest-state-funding-per-job-heres-the-breakdown/

    8. Sanchez, Melissa, and Jodi S. Cohen. “The Real Story Behind the Midnight Immigration Raid on a Chicago Apartment Building.” ProPublica, February 4, 2026. 

    9. City of Chicago Office of Inspector General. “Advisory Concerning Overtime Payments to Ineligible Employees.” January 21, 2026. https://news.wttw.com/sites/default/files/article/file-attachments/Advisory-Concerning-Overtime-Payments-to-Ineligible-Employees.pdf

    Ken Novak is the President and the Program|Communications chair of the Circle.

    847 414-4314

  • Chicago area investigative reporting review: January 2026

    January 28 @ 7:00 pm – 8:00 pm CST

    This is a new monthly discussion, on the topics raised by recent Chicago area investigative reporting. What we spend the most time on depends on where the interest of the group lies. The list is assembled by a Google LLM, and if you think it’s missed something important, please email Ken Novak.

    No need to read the articles. We’ll summarize key articles to lead into discussion. Questions? Call Ken Novak (847) 414-4314 or email him.

    The investigative landscape of the Chicago metropolitan area from late December 2025 through January 2026 (collected and summarized by Google’s NotebookLM on this PDF) presents a portrait of a municipal and state infrastructure under extraordinary strain, with ICE actions producing a fundamental conflict between federal enforcement mandates and local governance protections. This period has seen the culmination of several multi-year investigative threads that expose systemic failures in police accountability, the predatory nature of municipal property tax systems, and a significant escalation in the legal battle over federal immigration tactics. The reporting, primarily driven by non-profit newsrooms such as Injustice Watch (not recent reporting but a review of their 2025 work), the Illinois Answers Project, and South Side Weekly, along with traditional outlets like the Chicago Tribune and Chicago Sun-Times, reveals a deeply interconnected series of institutional crises. These crises are not merely contemporary occurrences but are rooted in historical patterns of mismanagement and a lack of transparency that have been documented in prior investigative works now reaching critical inflection points.
    The primary catalyst for investigative scrutiny during this window is, of course, theICE immigration enforcement surge that has fundamentally reshaped the relationship between the City of Chicago and the Department of Homeland Security. This operation has triggered a massive state-level lawsuit and prompted deep inquiries into the human costs of militarized policing in urban environments. Simultaneously, the Chicago Police Department faces a crisis of internal integrity, highlighted by investigations into the promotion of troubled officers and the theft of weapons from police facilities. Furthermore, the economic stability of the region’s most vulnerable residents is shown to be at risk through a “wealth-stripping” mechanism in the property tax system and the persistent failure of the state to enforce wage theft protections. This report synthesizes these findings, tracing the lineage of institutional failure and the emerging mechanisms of civic and legal resistance. [click here for there full annotated report]

    Here is a bibliography in author order with embedded links. The pdf report connects reporting with sources.

    Charles, Sam. “Chicago PD to hire more civilian investigators to tackle misconduct case backlog.” Chicago Tribune (via Police1), January 16, 2026.

    Disparti Law Group. “New Illinois Laws for 2026: Your Complete Guide to What’s Changing.” Accessed January 2026.

    Hing, Geoff, and Jill Castellano. “ICE Data Reveals What Happened to 1,600 People Arrested During Chicago’s Blitz.” The Marshall Project, December 18, 2025.

    Krishnamoorthi, Raja. Letter to Secretary Kristi Noem. January 6, 2026.

    Lee, Tori. “Trina Reynolds-Tyler, MPP’20, Wins Pulitzer Prize in Local Reporting.” University of Chicago Harris School of Public Policy, May 8, 2024.

    Masterson, Matt. “Illinois, Chicago Sue Trump Administration Over ‘Illegal’ Immigration Enforcement Tactics.” WTTW News, January 12, 2026.

    Masterson, Matt. “Jury Selected in Trial of Man Accused in Murder-for-Hire Plot Targeting Border Patrol Chief Greg Bovino.” WTTW News, January 20, 2026.

    National Immigrant Justice Center. “After the Blitz: What Our Chicago Neighbors Are Facing in ICE Detention.” December 10, 2025.

    Newman, Jonah. “Injustice Watch’s best work of 2025.” Injustice Watch, December 26, 2025.

    Nickeas, Peter, Tom Schuba, and Casey Toner. “Chicago Police Brass Had Rejected Troubled Cop’s Move to Elite Unit Before He Fatally Shot Partner.” Illinois Answers Project, January 15, 2026.

    Nickeas, Peter, Casey Toner, and Tom Schuba. “Gun Stolen From a Room Full of Chicago Cops Ended Up Being Used in a Series of Shootings.” Illinois Answers Project, May 2, 2025.

    Posner, Emeline. “The Castle on Drexel.” South Side Weekly, January 12, 2023 (updated December 9, 2025).

    Posner, Emeline. “What’s to Come for the 4800 Block of South Drexel Boulevard?” South Side Weekly, May 18, 2023 (updated June 14, 2023).

    Reynolds-Tyler, Trina, and Sarah Conway. “Families of the missing speak out about stigma, police and closure.” The TRiiBE, November 20, 2023.

    Reynolds-Tyler, Trina, and Sarah Conway. “What Happens When Your Friend, Sister, or Daughter Goes Missing?” Word In Black, April 2, 2024.

    Schencker, Lisa. “Lurie Children’s Hospital in Chicago scales back gender-affirming care, days after call for federal investigation.” Chicago Tribune, January 20, 2026.

    University of Chicago Data Science Institute. “DSI and The Patrick J. McGovern Foundation Invite the Next Generation to Imagine Data and AI for Good.” April 24, 2025.

    Wikipedia. “Amara Enyia.” Last modified [Date Unknown].

    Wikipedia. “Operation Midway Blitz.” Last modified [Date Unknown].

    Join us!

    Ken Novak is the President and the Program|Communications chair of the Circle.

    847 414-4314

  • Chicago area investigative reporting review: January 2026

    January 25 @ 2:00 pm – 3:30 pm CST

    We are evolving a new fourth Sunday discussion, on the topics raised by recent Chicago area investigative reporting. What we spend the most time on depends on where the interest of the group lies. The list is assembled by a Google LLM, and if you think it’s missed something important, please email Ken Novak.

    No need to read the articles. We’ll summarize key articles to lead into discussion. Questions? Call Ken Novak (847) 414-4314 or email him.

    The investigative landscape of the Chicago metropolitan area from late December 2025 through January 2026 (collected and summarized by Google’s NotebookLM on this PDF) presents a portrait of a municipal and state infrastructure under extraordinary strain, with ICE actions producing a fundamental conflict between federal enforcement mandates and local governance protections. This period has seen the culmination of several multi-year investigative threads that expose systemic failures in police accountability, the predatory nature of municipal property tax systems, and a significant escalation in the legal battle over federal immigration tactics. The reporting, primarily driven by non-profit newsrooms such as Injustice Watch (not recent reporting but a review of their 2025 work), the Illinois Answers Project, and South Side Weekly, along with traditional outlets like the Chicago Tribune and Chicago Sun-Times, reveals a deeply interconnected series of institutional crises. These crises are not merely contemporary occurrences but are rooted in historical patterns of mismanagement and a lack of transparency that have been documented in prior investigative works now reaching critical inflection points.
    The primary catalyst for investigative scrutiny during this window is, of course, the ICE immigration enforcement surge that has fundamentally reshaped the relationship between the City of Chicago and the Department of Homeland Security. This operation has triggered a massive state-level lawsuit and prompted deep inquiries into the human costs of militarized policing in urban environments. Simultaneously, the Chicago Police Department faces a crisis of internal integrity, highlighted by investigations into the promotion of troubled officers and the theft of weapons from police facilities. Furthermore, the economic stability of the region’s most vulnerable residents is shown to be at risk through a “wealth-stripping” mechanism in the property tax system and the persistent failure of the state to enforce wage theft protections. This report synthesizes these findings, tracing the lineage of institutional failure and the emerging mechanisms of civic and legal resistance. [click here for there full annotated report]

    Here is a bibliography in author order with embedded links. The pdf report connects reporting with sources.

    Charles, Sam. “Chicago PD to hire more civilian investigators to tackle misconduct case backlog.” Chicago Tribune (via Police1), January 16, 2026.

    Disparti Law Group. “New Illinois Laws for 2026: Your Complete Guide to What’s Changing.” Accessed January 2026.

    Hing, Geoff, and Jill Castellano. “ICE Data Reveals What Happened to 1,600 People Arrested During Chicago’s Blitz.” The Marshall Project, December 18, 2025.

    Krishnamoorthi, Raja. Letter to Secretary Kristi Noem. January 6, 2026.

    Lee, Tori. “Trina Reynolds-Tyler, MPP’20, Wins Pulitzer Prize in Local Reporting.” University of Chicago Harris School of Public Policy, May 8, 2024.

    Masterson, Matt. “Illinois, Chicago Sue Trump Administration Over ‘Illegal’ Immigration Enforcement Tactics.” WTTW News, January 12, 2026.

    Masterson, Matt. “Jury Selected in Trial of Man Accused in Murder-for-Hire Plot Targeting Border Patrol Chief Greg Bovino.” WTTW News, January 20, 2026.

    National Immigrant Justice Center. “After the Blitz: What Our Chicago Neighbors Are Facing in ICE Detention.” December 10, 2025.

    Newman, Jonah. “Injustice Watch’s best work of 2025.” Injustice Watch, December 26, 2025.

    Nickeas, Peter, Tom Schuba, and Casey Toner. “Chicago Police Brass Had Rejected Troubled Cop’s Move to Elite Unit Before He Fatally Shot Partner.” Illinois Answers Project, January 15, 2026.

    Nickeas, Peter, Casey Toner, and Tom Schuba. “Gun Stolen From a Room Full of Chicago Cops Ended Up Being Used in a Series of Shootings.” Illinois Answers Project, May 2, 2025.

    Posner, Emeline. “The Castle on Drexel.” South Side Weekly, January 12, 2023 (updated December 9, 2025).

    Posner, Emeline. “What’s to Come for the 4800 Block of South Drexel Boulevard?” South Side Weekly, May 18, 2023 (updated June 14, 2023).

    Reynolds-Tyler, Trina, and Sarah Conway. “Families of the missing speak out about stigma, police and closure.” The TRiiBE, November 20, 2023.

    Reynolds-Tyler, Trina, and Sarah Conway. “What Happens When Your Friend, Sister, or Daughter Goes Missing?” Word In Black, April 2, 2024.

    Schencker, Lisa. “Lurie Children’s Hospital in Chicago scales back gender-affirming care, days after call for federal investigation.” Chicago Tribune, January 20, 2026.

    University of Chicago Data Science Institute. “DSI and The Patrick J. McGovern Foundation Invite the Next Generation to Imagine Data and AI for Good.” April 24, 2025.

    Wikipedia. “Amara Enyia.” Last modified [Date Unknown].

    Wikipedia. “Operation Midway Blitz.” Last modified [Date Unknown].

    Join us!

    Ken Novak is the President and the Program|Communications chair of the Circle.

    847 414-4314

  • Following “The Watchdogs”: December 2025 investigative reports from WBEZ/Sun-Times

    Following “The Watchdogs”: December 2025 investigative reports from WBEZ/Sun-Times

    December 28, 2025 @ 2:00 pm – 3:30 pm CST

    This is the first of a new fourth Sunday series, replacing Katherine Ozment’s “Grace Without God” with a monthly view of the investigative reported by the Watchdogs team from Chicago Public Media and reported on WBEZ.org and Chicago.Suntimes.com.

    The articles are available on The Sun-Times website’s Watchdogs section.

    No need to read the articles. We’ll use summaries to promote discussion. Questions? Call Ken Novak (847) 414-4314..

    Join us!

    Ken Novak is the President and the Program|Communications chair of the Circle.

    847 414-4314

  • 2025 Annual Meeting

    2025 Annual Meeting

    November 30, 2025 @ 2:00 pm – 3:30 pm CST

    We’ll conduct our annual membership meeting, including voting on the 2026 budget and Board, on the Sunday after Thanksgiving.

    Whether you’r a member or not, join us!

    Members will get the meeting packet in the mail and e-mail.Not a member? Contact Ken Novak at (847) 414-4314 or ken@chicagoethical.org, to get the agenda, etc.

    847 414-4314

  • Journeys: “Grace Without God”

    Journeys: “Grace Without God”

    November 23, 2025 @ 2:00 pm – 3:30 pm CST

    Starting Sunday and or the next six months on the fourth Sunday afternoons, we will use Katherine Ozment’s “Grace Without God:The Search for Meaning, Purpose, and Belonging in a Secular Age”: as a platform from which to talk about our own journeys around how we chose, and choose, to live our lives.

    This Sunday, we’ll start with the book’s Introduction, Chaps 1 and 2: from “We’re nothing” to the start of a search for something. We’ll compare and contrast our own backgrounds with Ozment’s.

    The book was published in 2016, . A review in “The Humanist” said

    With ample statistics, concise historical references, and reliance on social research, Katherine Ozment sets the stage in her recently published book, Grace Without God, for determining whether secularists who seek connection and an understanding of life can find them in ways that are equally rewarding as for those who rely on religion and faith. But make no mistake: this is not a dry read. Ozment is an astute journalist with a keen ability to draw relevant and revelatory stories out of the like-minded individuals she meets while traveling the United States to research this book. Ozment weaves her own personal journey throughout Grace Without God, making it relatable to anyone who once had religion in his or her life and who often feels like something’s missing without it. – The Humanist, 28 June 2016

    “The book”Grace Without God” is available from libraries in print and e-book form (unfortunately, not in audio form, so far as we’ve found out). It’s also available for $11.59 plus tax on Amazon, if you have Prime.

    But, you don’t need to read “Grace Without God” to take part. We’ll start with a review of each month’s chapters’ principal narratives, then use it as the basis for a discussion of parallels or contrasts in our respective lives.

    You may be interested enough to pick up the book for the rest of the monthly discussions, or just drop for a topic you particularly want to dive into. Questions? Call Ken Novak (847) 414-4314..

    Join us!

    Ken Novak is the President and the Program|Communications chair of the Circle.

    847 414-4314

  • Freethinkers: Two Heroes and a Pariah

    Freethinkers: Two Heroes and a Pariah

    November 9, 2025 @ 2:00 pm – 3:30 pm CST

    Alternative History discussion, using Susan Jacoby’s “Freethinkers”: Intro, Chaps 1&2: Two heroes and a pariah: Jefferson, Madison, and Paine

    This is a new discussion group, with the Northeast Indiana EthicalHumanists, looking at less-told (and in some case actively muffled) stories from history

    These chapters of Jacoby’s book cover the decades preceding and following the Revolution. Three of the era’s most important “influencers” were Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, and Thomas Paine, all non-theists. 

    The book is available from libraries in print, e-book and audio form, but you don’t need to read “Freethinkers” to take part. We’ll start with a review of each month’s chapters’ principal narratives, then use it as the basis for a discussion of parallels in modern American life.

    In December, we’ll cover Chapters 3&4, covering abolitionists, the first wave of American feminists, and Abe Lincoln and his influences. By Aril, we’ll have covered the book.

    You may be interested enough to pick up the book for the rest of the monthly discussions, or just drop for an era you particularly want to dive into. Questions? Call Ken Novak (847) 414-4314..

    Join us!

    Ken Novak is the President and the Program|Communications chair of the Circle.

    847 414-4314